Skip to content
DramaDrop

MY BROTHER SUED ME FOR $200,000. THEN WE ASKED WHERE MY SHARE OF THE PROFITS WAS.

Chapter 3 – IF I WAS HIS PARTNER, HE OWED ME ANSWERS

Once I decided to fight, my fear did not disappear.
It changed shape.
Before, fear had felt like fog.
I didn’t know what Sutton might claim.
I didn’t know what the lawsuit could do.
I didn’t know how far my parents would go.
After Cordelia scheduled Sutton’s deposition, the fear became something I could point at.
A date.
A room.
Questions.
Answers.
Consequences.
And Sutton reacted exactly the way Cordelia predicted.
Badly.
Two days after the deposition notice went out, Mom called me.
“What are you doing to your brother?”
I was standing near a construction trailer at a project site, hard hat tucked beneath my arm.
Excavators rumbled in the distance.
I moved away from the crew.
“What am I doing?”
“You’re forcing him into some interrogation.”
“It’s called a deposition.”
“He says your lawyer is trying to humiliate him.”
“He sued me.”
“Why do you keep saying that?”
I almost smiled.
“Because every conversation you have about this seems designed to forget it.”
“He just wants what he thinks is fair.”
“Then he can explain why it’s fair.”
“Can’t you stop this before somebody says something they regret?”
I looked out over the job site.
Steel rose against the gray morning sky.
Workers moved between columns with purpose.
Everything had sequence.
Load.
Support.
Cause.
Effect.
Maybe that was why the lawsuit disturbed me so much.
Sutton’s version of reality had no structure.
Money came from me because he needed it.
Success belonged to him.
Failure belonged to circumstances.
And when the money stopped, responsibility somehow traveled backward until it reached me.
“Mom,” I said, “if Sutton believes what he filed, answering questions shouldn’t humiliate him.”
She went quiet.
I waited.
Then she said, “You sound different.”
“I am different.”
“I don’t like it.”
That hurt.
I hated that it hurt.
But I answered anyway.
“I know.”
Cordelia began preparing me for my own deposition too.
Sutton’s side had the right to question me.
She warned me not to argue.
Not to guess.
Not to fill silence.
“Answer what’s asked,” she said. “Nothing more.”
“That’s it?”
“That’s harder than you think when the person asking questions is implying you betrayed your brother.”
She was right.
Grady questioned me first.
The deposition took place in a conference room with a court reporter at one end of the table.
Sutton wasn’t there.
I was almost grateful.
Grady looked exactly the way he sounded over the phone.
Gray hair.
Expensive but conservative suit.
Reading glasses low on his nose.
Professional.
Controlled.
Not cruel.
That surprised me.
I had spent weeks imagining him as some kind of predator Sutton had hired.
Instead, Grady seemed like a man doing a job for a client who had told him a story.
That distinction became important later.
He started gently.
My education.
My career.
Income.
Relationship with Sutton.
History of financial assistance.
Then the questions narrowed.
“Did you believe your brother’s vehicle resale operation could become profitable?”
“Yes.”
“At any point?”
“Yes.”
“Did you tell him that?”
“Probably.”
“Did you encourage him?”
“Yes.”
“Did you provide money?”
“Yes.”
“More than once?”
“Yes.”
“Did you expect the business to succeed?”
“I hoped it would.”
Grady glanced at his notes.
“Did you ever refer to your contributions as an investment?”
I thought carefully.
“Not that I remember.”
“You don’t deny it’s possible?”
Cordelia spoke.
“Don’t characterize his testimony.”
Grady nodded.
I answered.
“I don’t remember ever calling it an investment.”
“Did you expect repayment?”
“Sometimes I hoped Sutton would repay money he borrowed.”
“Sometimes?”
“Some money was clearly help. Some he said he would repay.”
“So there were no formal distinctions.”
“There were distinctions in the conversations.”
“But not written contracts.”
“No.”
Grady leaned back.
“Mr. Mercer, isn’t it true that you wanted your brother’s business to become successful?”
“Yes.”
“And you provided capital because you believed it could.”
“I gave my brother money because he asked for help.”
“Those things aren’t mutually exclusive, are they?”
“No.”
My chest tightened.
I understood what he was doing.
Taking facts that were true and placing them close enough together that they began to resemble Sutton’s story.
I believed in my brother.
I gave him money.
I hoped the business succeeded.
All true.
But belief was not ownership.
Hope was not a contract.
Love was not a financing commitment.
Grady continued.
“Did you ever tell Sutton you were done supporting the business before the dispute that led to this case?”
“I told him I wasn’t giving him another fifteen thousand dollars.”
“Before that.”
“I’d told him I was concerned.”
“But had you said, Adam Mercer will provide no further funding?”
“No.”
“So from his perspective, your refusal was unexpected.”
“I can’t speak to his perspective.”
For the first time, Cordelia glanced at me approvingly.
Grady noticed.
He smiled faintly.
“Fair answer.”
The deposition lasted nearly four hours.
By the end, I was exhausted.
Not because Grady had trapped me.
He hadn’t.
Because revisiting years of family dynamics in the language of contracts and reliance felt obscene.
At one point, he showed me one of Sutton’s texts.
I can’t do the next deal without you.
Grady asked, “What did you understand this to mean?”
“That he wanted money.”
“Did you understand he depended on you for financing?”
“Yes.”
“Then you knew withdrawal of financing could affect the business.”
I looked at him.
“If somebody depends on me continuing to give them money, that doesn’t mean I promised to do it forever.”
Grady paused.
Cordelia didn’t object.
“Is that your position?”
“That’s the truth.”
When it ended, I walked with Cordelia into the parking garage.
“How bad was that?”
“You did fine.”
“Fine as in actually fine or lawyer fine?”
She smiled.
“Actually fine.”
I loosened my tie.
“He made it sound reasonable for a minute.”
“That’s his job.”
“What if somebody believes him?”
“Then we show them the rest.”
“The rest?”
She pressed the elevator button.
“Your brother’s deposition is next.”
The doors opened.
Before stepping inside, she looked at me.
“Remember something. Grady can build an argument from your generosity only if Sutton can explain what he gave you in return.”
The elevator descended.
I thought of Jolene’s question.
Where was my share?
Sutton’s deposition was scheduled nine days later.
I was allowed to attend.
Cordelia asked whether I wanted to.
I almost said no.
The thought of sitting across from my brother while lawyers dissected our relationship made me sick.
Then I remembered my parents’ house.
The forty-five-thousand-dollar spreadsheet.
The demand for two hundred thousand dollars.
“Yes,” I said. “I want to be there.”
Two nights before the deposition, Sutton called me directly.
It was the first time we had spoken since before the lawsuit.
I stared at his name on the screen.
Jolene was reading beside me in bed.
She saw the phone.
“Your choice,” she said.
I answered.
“Hello.”
Silence.
Then Sutton’s voice.
“You happy?”
I sat up.
“About what?”
“This whole circus.”
I swung my feet to the floor.
“You sued me.”
“Yeah, keep saying that.”
I almost laughed.
Mom’s exact complaint.
Maybe they had all been discussing how irritating it was that I refused to forget the central fact.
“Sutton, what do you want?”
“You could end this tomorrow.”
“How?”
“Make an offer.”
“No.”
“You won’t even talk?”
“I’m talking now.”
“You know what I mean.”
“Yes.”
“Then why are you making this ugly?”
My grip tightened.
“You filed a lawsuit demanding two hundred thousand dollars from me.”
“Because you screwed me.”
“How?”
“You pulled out when I needed you.”
“I was never in.”
“Bull.”
“I gave my brother money.”
“You funded the business.”
“I helped you.”
“Same thing.”
“No. It isn’t.”
Sutton laughed bitterly.
“You always do that.”
“Do what?”
“Make everything sound clean.”
I frowned.
“You got your degree. You got the job. You got the house. You married the nurse. Everything lines up for Adam.”
I stood and walked into the hallway so Jolene wouldn’t have to hear.
“You think my life just lined itself up?”
“You never lost what I lost.”
There it was.
The knee.
Always the knee.
“Sutton, I was twenty-one when you got hurt. I felt terrible for you.”
“You have no idea.”
“Maybe not.”
“No. You don’t.”
His voice had changed.
For one second, beneath the anger, I heard something else.
The boy in the framed photograph.
The one who believed a stadium full of people might someday know his name.
“I’m sorry that happened to you,” I said.
“Don’t.”
“I mean it.”
“I don’t want pity.”
“Then stop turning your pain into my debt.”
Silence.
I could hear his breathing.
“You think you’re better than me.”
“No.”
“You always have.”
“No, Sutton. I think I’m responsible for my choices.”
“And I’m not?”
“I think you’ve spent a long time making sure somebody else always is.”
The line went dead.
I stood in the dark hallway for a while.
When I returned to the bedroom, Jolene had set her book aside.
“What happened?”
“I think he hates me.”
She shook her head.
“I don’t think that’s what this is.”
“What is it?”
“He hates what your life means about his.”
I looked at her.
“That he could have made different choices.”
She didn’t say it cruelly.
That made it worse.
The next morning, Mom sent a message.
I heard you said some terrible things to your brother.
I did not answer.
Neither did I answer my aunt.
Or my cousin.
Or Dad when he called twice that night.
For the first time, I let other people be uncomfortable without volunteering to make them comfortable again.
Sutton’s deposition began at nine on a Thursday.
He arrived with Grady.
My brother looked older than I remembered.
Not old.
Worn.
There were deeper lines around his mouth, and his hair had thinned at the temples.
For half a second, I wanted to hug him.
Then he looked at me.
His expression hardened.
The feeling disappeared.
We sat across from one another.
The court reporter swore him in.
Cordelia arranged her papers.
“Mr. Mercer,” she began, “you understand you’re testifying under oath?”
“Yes.”
“You understand that means your answers must be truthful?”
“Yes.”
She asked basic questions first.
Name.
Address.
Work history.
Then she moved to the business.
“When did you first believe your brother Adam became your business partner?”
Sutton shifted.
“When he started funding me.”
“What date?”
“I don’t remember the exact date.”
“Was it before or after the twelve-thousand-dollar payment?”
“Around then.”
“Did you tell Adam at that time he was becoming a partner?”
“He knew.”
“That wasn’t my question.”
Grady leaned forward.
“Let him answer.”
Cordelia didn’t look away from Sutton.
“Did you tell your brother, using the word partner, that he was becoming your business partner?”
Sutton glanced at Grady.
“I don’t remember exactly what words we used.”
“So you cannot identify a conversation in which you told Adam he was a partner?”
“We had an understanding.”
“What was Adam’s ownership percentage?”
Sutton hesitated.
“We didn’t put a number on it.”
“What percentage of profits was he entitled to?”
“It wasn’t structured like that yet.”
“What percentage of losses was he responsible for?”
“We were building the business.”
“Did Adam have authority to choose which vehicles you bought?”
“He trusted me on that.”
“That’s not my question.”
Sutton’s jaw tightened.
“No.”
“Could Adam prevent you from purchasing a vehicle?”
“No.”
“Did he approve repair budgets?”
“No.”
“Did he have access to your business records?”
“We talked.”
“Did he have access to your records?”
“No.”
“Did he have authority over your bank account?”
“No.”
“Did he negotiate with mechanics?”
“No.”
“Did he negotiate with buyers?”
“No.”
“Did he participate in setting sale prices?”
“No.”
“Did you ever provide him with a written statement showing revenue?”
“No.”
“Expenses?”
“No.”
“Profit?”
“No.”
Cordelia paused.
I felt something change in the room.
Grady felt it too.
He leaned back slowly.
Cordelia picked up another page.
“Did you ever pay Adam any portion of the proceeds from a vehicle sale?”
Sutton’s eyes moved toward me.
“No.”
“Why not?”
“Because we were reinvesting.”
“Who decided that?”
“I did.”
“Did Adam agree?”
“He knew we were trying to grow.”
“Did Adam receive any payment from the business at any point?”
“No.”
“Salary?”
“No.”
“Profit distribution?”
“No.”
“Reimbursement?”
“No.”
“Anything?”
“No.”
Cordelia let the silence sit.
Sutton looked at the table.
Then she asked the question Jolene had asked me at our dining-room table.
“If Adam was your business partner, Mr. Mercer, where was his share?”
Sutton looked up.
“We weren’t at that stage.”
“What stage?”
“The business wasn’t stable.”
“So his obligations began immediately, but his rights would begin later?”
Grady objected to the form of the question.
Cordelia rephrased.
“When was Adam supposed to begin receiving profits?”
“When there were real profits.”
“Were any vehicles sold for more than their purchase and repair cost?”
Sutton shifted again.
“Some.”
“So there were profitable transactions.”
“Some.”
“Did Adam receive any of that money?”
“No.”
“Why not?”
“I told you. We were building.”
“Did Adam agree to leave his share in the business?”
Sutton’s face reddened.
“He trusted me.”
“Did he agree?”
“I don’t remember.”
Cordelia turned a page.
“Let’s discuss the additional fifteen thousand dollars.”
My heart began pounding.
“When did you ask Adam for that money?”
Sutton gave the approximate date.
“What did you tell him?”
“That I had two opportunities.”
“Did you tell him he was contractually obligated to provide the money?”
“No.”
“Did you tell him he had a duty as your partner to provide it?”
“Not in those words.”
“What words did you use?”
Sutton looked toward me.
“I said I needed him.”
Cordelia waited.
“And?”
“And he said no.”
“What happened then?”
“We argued.”
“What did you say?”
“I don’t remember everything.”
Cordelia placed a printed message in front of him.
“Does this refresh your recollection?”
Sutton read it.
His expression changed.
I knew the message.
So I’m not worth helping anymore?
Cordelia asked, “You described the money as help, correct?”
“I was upset.”
“You did not say, ‘You’re breaching our partnership agreement.’”
“No.”
“You did not say, ‘You promised to provide financing.’”
“No.”
“You did not say, ‘You’re violating our contract.’”
“No.”
“You asked whether you were worth helping.”
Sutton’s fingers tightened around the page.
“Yes.”
The room was completely quiet.
Then Cordelia pulled out another message.
“This one is from after the twelve-thousand-dollar transfer.”
Sutton read it.
Thanks, man. Seriously. You saved my ass.
“Did you send that?”
“Yes.”
“Did you mention an investment?”
“No.”
“An ownership percentage?”
“No.”
“A partnership?”
“No.”
Another.
I know you don’t have to keep helping me. I appreciate it.
Cordelia placed it down.
My brother stared at it.
I stopped breathing.
She read the sentence aloud.
“You wrote, ‘I know you don’t have to keep helping me.’ Correct?”
Sutton didn’t answer.
Grady said quietly, “You need to answer.”
“Yes.”
Cordelia leaned back.
“If you knew Adam did not have to keep helping you, why are you suing him for refusing to keep helping you?”
Sutton’s face changed.
For one second, all the legal language disappeared.
The claims.
The damages.
The business terminology.
He looked at me exactly the way he had the night I refused the fifteen thousand dollars.
Angry.
Hurt.
Abandoned.
“They don’t understand,” he said.
Cordelia stayed calm.
“Who?”
“My family.”
Grady shifted.
“Sutton, answer the question.”
But Sutton was looking at me now.
“He said he believed in me.”
I felt the room narrow.
Cordelia waited.
Sutton’s voice rose.
“He knew I needed capital. He knew I couldn’t keep doing it without him. He kept saying he wanted me to succeed.”
My chest tightened.
“Mr. Mercer,” Cordelia said, “did Adam promise to finance you indefinitely?”
“He didn’t have to say indefinitely.”
“Did he promise?”
“He was supposed to keep helping me.”
That sentence landed harder than anything in the complaint.
Not investing.
Not partnering.
Helping.
Cordelia asked, “Why?”
Sutton’s eyes never left mine.
“Because he’s my brother.”
And there it was.
The whole case.
Not a business partnership.
Not a contract.
Not a financing agreement.
A belief.
My brother believed that because I had helped him before, I was required to keep helping him.
Grady removed his glasses.
“Sutton,” he said quietly.
My brother turned.
Grady’s expression had changed.
Not anger.
Concern.
“Let’s take a break.”

Similar stories